Jim True-Frost

as Pastor Shane

as Isaac

as Ben

as Donnie Prince

as Rogers

as Doctor

as Hugh Winston

as William Gibbs

as Jack Hewitt

as Mike Anderson

as Ryland

as Noah Lane

as Jesse

as Buzz

as David Bailey

as Donald Hornig

as Mayor Walton Green

as Bradley Hahn

as Father McGreggor

as Rector Dave Hynes

as Nathan

as John Saya

as Ron Ballard

as Max Perkins

as Gordon Kemp

as Anson Samuels

as Lyle Greene

as James Woodrow

as Seth Kleinberg

as Ted Pratchett

as Stephen Campbell

as Dave Keppling

as Roland 'Prez' Pryzbylewski

as Roland 'Prez' Pryzbylewski

as Jay Lippman

as Thomas Banks

as Sam

as George Buxton

as Bruce Elwin

as JoJo Sweeney (as Jim True)