Jim Beaver

as Radio Host

as Sheriff Jedediah Judd

as Sergeant Ward

as Whitney Ellsworth (archive footage)

as Doctor

as The Boss

as Crabtree

as Joseph Taylor Elliott / First Engineering Officer Nathaniel Wintringer (voice)

as Lee

as Carter Cushing

as The Captain

as J. Wright Mooar

as Jack Tugdon

as Franck

as Wisdom

as Agent Hammond

as Duke Grover

as Ranger Tony

as Sheriff Ritter

as Jefferson Bent

as Smiling Peanut Patron #1

as Agent Jason Reiling

as Agent Eric Ashton

as Danny Leland

as Pinkerton Detective Graves

as Ricky's Father

as Detective Ira

as Proclamation Officer

as Traveling Blacksmith

as Deputy Willie Rudd

as Clarkson

as Oscar

as Spivey Irick

as Maj. Trimble

as Craig Hraboy

as Plant Manager

as Earl Smith

as Sheriff Jack Edzard

as Motel Manager

as FBI Man

as Smuggler (uncredited)

as Pedestrian

as Cowboy Player (uncredited)

as Client (uncredited)

as B.E.A.T. Member (uncredited)

as Pops

as Harrison Farber

as Bobby Singer

as Spencer

as Robert Singer

as Andy

as Kenneth

as NSA Agent Jake Neville

as Chuck

as Lawson

as Arliss Fontenot

as Donald Beckwith

as Lee Rosky

as John Franklin Fry

as Shelby Parlow

as Frank Loomis

as Eddie Stokes

as Charlie Mills

as Cobb Holwell

as Lawson

as Vietnam Joe

as Hannah’s father

as Pete Dillingham

as Carter Reese

as Lloyd Cole

as 'Uncle' Nick Vukovic

as George Gibbons

as Bobby Singer

as Sheriff Williams

as Whitney Ellsworth

as Captain Tom O'Rourke

as Hank Ferris

as Sheriff Sam Boggs

as Sheriff Ronald Mathis

as Ranger Diggory

as Daniel Leonard

as Prison Officer

as Fred Zito

as Stanley Tanner

as Gary

as Carl

as Tony

as Detective McKissick

as Happy Doug

as Edgar Allan Poe

as Donald Cleary

as Leland DuParte

as Coroner

as Henry Barnes

as Ranger Virgil

as Duke Miller

as Detective Earl Gaddis

as Wetstone

as Defense Attorney

as Barney Sutler