Jay Hindle

Actor 1993–2026 (33 year career)

6.6 avg rating

Highest Rated

The X-Files

1993 · as Sitcom Joe

8.4

Supernatural

2005 · as Man

8.3

When Calls the Heart

2014 · as Sir Lionel

8.2

Known For

Film

Dragged Across Concrete

Guy in Elevator

Film

A December Bride

Jack Evans

Film

Write Before Christmas

Wes

Film

Infidelity in Suburbia

Bill

Film

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Heist and Seek

David Reyes

Film

Hearts of Christmas

Eric Lang

Film

Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas

Peter Bishop

Film

Supernatural

Man

Filmography

Acting (27)

Movies (19)

Hunting Matthew Nichols

2026 Upcoming

as Randall Nichols

Apr 10

Ms. Match

2023

as John

5.6

The Best Version of Love

as Felix

Sins in the Family

as Max

Dying for a Family

as Keith

North to Home

as Jerry

Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas

2022

as Peter Bishop

6.6

A Great North Christmas

2021

as Jonathan

5.5

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Heist and Seek

2020

as David Reyes

7.4

Dragged Across Concrete

2019

as Guy in Elevator

6.6

Write Before Christmas

as Wes

A Christmas Duet

as Mark

The Story of Us

as Eric

Infidelity in Suburbia

2017

as Bill

6.2

Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval

as Larry

A December Bride

as Jack Evans

Hearts of Christmas

as Eric Lang

Karen Kingsbury's A Time to Dance

as Sam Taylor

I Am

as Lance Vita

Television (8)

Somewhere Between

as Chad Wolofsky

Colony

as Representative

Supergirl

as Joe Ford

When Calls the Heart

as Sir Lionel

Motive

as Liam Kline

Arrow

as Officer Benton

Supernatural

as Man

The X-Files

as Sitcom Joe