Hayley McFarland

as Rachel

as Syd

as Olivia

as Annie Parker-Reed

as Dawn Russell

as Sister Agnes

as Nancy

as Lori Carline

as Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens

as Young Karen

as (voice)

as Monica Harper

as Mary

as Ms. Marcos

as Emily Lightman

as Emily Lightman

as Petula

as Brooke Putner

as Bonnie

as Nikki Heaps

as Rory Williams

as Katie Owen

as Jamie Portman

as Addy Gilroy

as Emily Latham

as Marcia

as Jenna Fox