Brian McElhaney

WriterDirectorCrewActorProducer 2005–2026 (21 year career)

6.2 avg rating

Highest Rated

How I Met Your Mother

2005 · as Justin

8.1

Livers of Darkness: Making "Dude Bro Party Massacre III"

2016 · as Himself

8.0

Unforgettable

2011 · as Officer Tim Gosling

7.2

Known For

Film

The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Times Square Bystander

Film

Young Adult

Book Associate

Film

Plus One

Martin the Bartender

Film

Much Ado About Nothing

Second Watchman

Film

Arthur

College Student

Film

Dude Bro Party Massacre III

Turtleneck Bro

Film

How I Met Your Mother

Justin

Film

Greener Grass

Brian

Filmography

Acting (21)

Movies (17)

You're an Angel

2024

as Tate

Early to Rise

2021

as Russian Game Show Host

The Club

2020

as Brian

7.0

Plus One

2019

as Martin the Bartender

6.8

The Mystery

2019

as Brian

Pregame

2016

as Harry

Livers of Darkness: Making "Dude Bro Party Massacre III"

2016

as Himself

8.0

Dude Bro Party Massacre III

as Turtleneck Bro

Greener Grass

as Brian

The Amazing Spider-Man 2

2014

as Times Square Bystander

6.5

Balls Out

2014

as Chance

4.2

Much Ado About Nothing

as Second Watchman

Young Adult

as Book Associate

Arthur

as College Student

Searching for Sonny

as Gary Noble

Eagles Are Turning People Into Horses

2011

as Nick Panzer

Suckerpunch

2010

as Martin Finch

4.6

Television (4)

After Midnight

2024

as Self

5.5

Unforgettable

2011

as Officer Tim Gosling

7.2

All-Nighters

2008

as Brian

How I Met Your Mother

2005

as Justin

8.1

Crew (7)

Movies (7)

Over Your Dead Body

2026 Upcoming

Screenplay

Apr 24

Pizza Movie

2026

Director

Pizza Movie

2026

Writer

Demi Adejuyigbe: Is Going to Do One (1) Backflip

2025

Thanks

6.6

Eagles Are Turning People Into Horses

2011

Director

Eagles Are Turning People Into Horses

2011

Producer

Eagles Are Turning People Into Horses

2011

Writer